SWOT analysis of building-integrated solar systems

Which solar envelope systems are available for sale and what are their main features? A new report that is being drafted in Task 56 (Building Integrated Solar Envelope Systems for HVAC and Lighting) of the IEA Solar Heating and Cooling Programme will provide stakeholders with a comprehensive SWOT analysis of commercial and prototype solutions to shed some light on the diversity in this sector. Titled State-of-the-art and SWOT analysis of building integrated solar envelope systems, the document is scheduled for publication on the Task 56 website this August.
Photo: Conserval Engineering - Solarwall
 
The Task 56 report will contain a review of available solar envelope systems, describing the technical details of their facade integration and effects on thermal comfort and energy consumption in buildings. Its authors will also write about non-technical issues such as aesthetic features, architectural integration and customer acceptance. Even though the focus is on mass-market solutions, the report will likewise include a discussion of some custom-made and laboratory-scale products.
 
Solar envelope solutions will be categorised as
  • Solar harvesting systems for electricity or heat production
  • Solar systems for controlling daylight and incident solar radiation to lower a building’s energy needs
  • Hybrid systems, which combine active and passive technologies
 
The report will describe eight solutions of the first category, four of which will be commercially available products, while the other four will be considered prototype systems.
 

Solution

Technological readiness

More information

SolarWall heating systems

Commercial

http://solarwall.com/en/home.php

AventaSolar building-integrated collectors

Commercial

https://aventasolar.com

MatrixAir solar air heating

Commercial

www.matrixairheating.com

Kromatix – multi-coloured BIPV elements

Commercial

https://www.swissinso.com

SunRise – modular BI solar thermal system

Prototype

n/a

Modular BIPV/T

Prototype

n/a

HVAC via Facade: Facade element + integrated heat pump

Prototype

Report in German

BIPV/T prefabricated timber panels

Prototype

http://4rineu.eu

Active solar envelope systems
Source: IEA SHC Task 56
 
The description of each solution has been written by the supplier of the technology, i.e., a research lab or a manufacturer. “We are sharing our analysis with other technology providers, so that we can offer a broader portfolio of solutions to building developers,” said Roberto Fedrizzi, Operating Agent of Task 56. Soon, parts of the report will be posted online to give manufacturers and providers the opportunity to add products, by sending an email to Fedrizzi, who is also the Coordinator of the Sustainable Heating and Cooling Systems research group at Eurac Research, based in Italy.
 
SWOT analysis
A SWOT analysis has been conducted regarding each solution described in the report, to identify strengths (S) and weaknesses (W), as well as opportunities (O) for growth and threats (T) created by external stimuli. Strengths and weaknesses are factors that are closely linked to a product and can be controlled by the developers. By contrast, opportunities and threats are external factors which affect the entire industry and are outside the influence of technology developers and suppliers.
 
SWOT, therefore, is a product analysis method, whose aim is to increase awareness of potential and critical issues that could have an impact on the success of a product in the market and help with strategic portfolio management. SWOT analysis results in strategies that build on strengths and avoid weaknesses, to seek out opportunities and counter threat

Photo: Aventa Solar

Building-integrated AventaSolar combi system on passive houses in Oslo, Norway
Photo: Aventa Solar
 
High-performance polymers for building-integrated solar collectors
One commercially available product to be featured in the report is AventaSolar’s building-integrated solar collector, which supplies domestic hot water or space heating, or both. It includes a polymer absorber with a transparent cover. Available in different lengths, this modular unit replaces conventional roof or building envelope materials. The innovative concept uses high-performance polymers processed into twin-wall sheets. It was demonstrated as early as at the beginning of 2010.
 

STRENGTHS

  • Modular design: customisable length allows for easy and architecturally appealing integration into roof and facade
  • Low-weight ensures trouble-free handling during transport and installation
  • Collector roof or facade installation without the requirement for an HVAC specialist; rather, can be set up by any skilled building envelope installer
  • Cost reduction thanks to methods for processing polymer materials, installation of non-pressurised collector and implementation of simple drainback solar loop design
  • Environmentally friendly owing to use of water as heat transfer fluid

WEAKNESSES

  • Non-pressurised collector and solar loop have yet to be very common and are met with scepticism by heating industry
  • Non-pressurised collectors are not directly compatible with conventional solar system components
  • Drainback collector loop design in high-rise buildings requires solar pump with significantly higher electricity consumption compared to conventional solar thermal systems

OPPORTUNITIES

  • Successful integration examples could inspire architects and decision-makers to adopt solution
  • European directives and global agreements on lowering carbon emissions in construction sector are fertile ground for cost-effective RES solutions

THREATS

  • Scepticism or little knowledge regarding high-performance polymers might hinder market adoption
  • National or regional building regulations prevent integration of certain polymer materials into building envelope
  • Competing technologies become increasingly cost-competitive
SWOT analysis of AventaSolar collectors
Source: IEA SHC Task 56
 
Photo: Eurac Resaerch
View of internal (left) and external (right) surface of Sunrise facade module installed inside test chamber at EUREC, Italy
Photo: Eurac Resaerch
 
Integrated product under development
Among the solutions at laboratory scale, one that is certainly worth mentioning is the Sunrise – Modular BI solar thermal system, developed and tested by Italian-based research organisation EURAC. It is a metal and glass curtain wall facade module that combines a solar thermal collector on the outside and a storage tank with a capacity of around 50 litres, as well as a radiant panel, on the inside. It uses solar-generated heat to meet demand for space heating and hot water and can provide heating and cooling energy for thermal comfort. The target market is the tertiary building sector, mainly offices.
 

STRENGHTS

  • Heating and cooling technology is integrated into facade, creating more living space
  • Design and installation have been simplified; a hydraulic module, functioning as a hydronic and control unit, is used to manage heat supply
  • Facade is modular and can be adapted to fulfil different width and height requirements
  • Energy flow metering in hydraulic unit, a new facade function, adds value to entire concept

WEAKNESSES

  • Visual aspects cannot be changed and need to be accepted by architect and customer
  • Shading in urban context influences performance and payback of entire façade concept
  • Investment costs in solar-integrated façade much higher than in conventional solutions
  • Lifespan of integrated façade solution barely quantifiable
  • Facade mullions specifically designed for pipe installation

OPPORTUNITIES

  • Solar thermal collectors with highly valued visual characteristics available for sale
  • Facades of high-rise buildings are rarely used
  • Solution can be adapted for small multifamily buildings

THREATS

  • Architects’ acceptance is major barrier to overcome
  • Certification of safety and energy performance of facade module is time-consuming and expensive if wide range of national and international standards is taken into account
  • Fossil fuel energy cost is comparatively low and incentive schemes often ignore innovation and CO2 emission savings owing to technological advances
SWOT analysis of Sunrise system
Source: IEA SHC Task 56
 
The article was written by Riccardo Battisti, a solar thermal consultant and market researcher working at Ambiente Italia (Rome, Italy).
 
Organisations mentioned in this article:

 

Share/Save

By continuing to use the site, you agree to the use of cookies. Find out more by following this link. Accept